1974 – Billy Stevenson / Sam Lenarduzzi
1975 – Sam Lenarduzzi
1976 – Bruce Wilson
1977 – Bruce Wilson
1978 – Jon Sammels
1979 – John Craven

1980 – Alan Ball / John Craven
1981 – Terry Yorath
1982 – Terry Yorath
1983 – Peter Lorimer
1984 – Bob Lenarduzzi
1987 – Shaun Lowther
1988 – John Catliff
1989 – John Catliff

1990 – John Catliff
1991 – John Catliff
1992 – John Catliff
1993 – John Catliff
1994 – Rick Celebrini
1995 – Rick Celebrini
1996 – Steve Macdonald
1997 – Steve Macdonald
1998 – Steve Macdonald
1999 – Paul Dailly

2000 – Paul Dailly
2001 – Kevin Holness
2002 – Paul Dailly
2003 – Paul Dailly
2004 – Alfredo Valente
2005 – Jeff Clarke
2006 – Jeff Clarke
2007 – Jeff Clarke
2008 – Adrian Cann / Jeff Clarke
2009 – Martin Nash

2010 – Martin Nash
2011 – Jay DeMerit
2012 – Jay DeMerit
2013 – Jay DeMerit
2014 – Jay DeMerit / Pedro Morales
2015 – Pedro Morales
2016 – Pedro Morales
2017 – Kendall Waston
2018 – Kendall Waston
2019 – Jon Erice

2020 – Russell Teibert
2021 – Russell Teibert
2022 – Russell Teibert
2023 – Russell Teibert
2024 – Ryan Gauld